Before I get on with this, I ought to note a couple of things. First, I worked on my dissertation today, reading five articles and incorporating four of them into the section I am working on. Second, I am a casual fan of comic books generally and the Marvel universe specifically; I never got into collecting comics, but I do like to read them.
I watched the "motion comic" Astonishing X-Men: Gifted on Netflix today, and I must say that I was not impressed. Despite being written by Whedon, I found the dialogue a bit stilted and jerky. The voicing was not, in most cases, what it needed to be; Wolverine is not nearly surly (or Canadian) enough, for example, even if the stream of profanity he releases at one point is entirely in keeping with the character. The art, although pretty while still, is uncomfortably jerky in motion, looking like nothing so much as cardboard cutouts on popsicle sticks. And the unnecessary division into thirteen- or fourteen-minute "chapters" heightens the disjunction, interrupting the narrative uncomfortably and needlessly complicating what is an already...non-flowing presentation.
If it is a representative example of the "motion comic" genre, I want nothing to do with the whole damned thing.
I fully anticipate hate mail over this one. It has been a while since I've really gotten good examples of it, so please, fire away. Jerks.